New Books in Finance Podcast: Banking on Freedom

Think running an insurance company or a bank is hard?  Try doing it as an African-American woman in the Jim Crow South.  Shennette Garrett-Scott‘s new book, Banking on Freedom: Black Women in U.S. Finance Before the New Deal (Columbia University Press, 2019) tells the fascinating story of just such an endeavor, first the Independent Order of St. Luke, and then the St. Luke Penny Savings Bank, founded in Richmond in 1903.  Along the way, she tells the tale of force-of-nature strong women, particularly Maggie Lena Walker, who wouldn’t take no for an answer as she built up a culture of business and entrepreneurship …

Continue Reading

An argument for higher rates…..

In a recent column, Bloomberg columnist John Authers asked “Wherefore the lack of inflationary pressure? The most coherent explanation stems from the effect low rates have in dampening the capitalist process of creative destruction. Simply put, low rates allow those companies that would normally fail to survive and stay in business. That means that capital is wasted and growth remains far below what it ought to be otherwise.” By day, I manage a portfolio of dividend-paying, dividend-growing companies that are supposed to get killed by raising rates.  While that has not happened, I actually want to see long rates rise, …

Continue Reading

Risk, Damned Risk, and Alpha, 2.0 (sounds like Lies, Damned Lies, and Statistics)

Over the past few days, Bloomberg columnist John Authers has been hosting an online discussion of Peter Bernstein’s Capital Ideas from 1996.  Much of the back and forth has been about using volatility (standard deviation of mostly shareprice-based returns) as the measure of risk in investing. That’s the preferred approach in Modern Portfolio Theory.  In recent years, I have made a cottage industry of bashing MPT’s definition of risk. I’ve also likened alpha (the excess or deficit of return after adjustment for risk or specific factor exposure) to Santa Claus: He may or may not exist, but it makes a …

Continue Reading

Bloomberg Discussion of Bernstein’s Capital Ideas

(The full version of my contribution to an online discussion organized by John Authers/Bloomberg. An edited version appeared on the Bloomberg website.) When assessing Capital Ideas, it is critical to distinguish between the messenger and the message. Through the Journal of Portfolio Management (starting in 1974), and then in Capital Ideas (1992), Peter Bernstein clearly succeeded in achieving his goal of bringing gown to town, as well as explaining to a broader audience in Capital Ideas what the complex and rather dry Journal of Finance articles actually meant.  His enthusiasm and wit and wisdom emerge on almost every page. He …

Continue Reading

New Books in Finance podcast…

I’m pleased to announce that I have become the host of the New Books in Finance podcast, now a dedicated channel on the New Books Network. (My previous NBN interviews fell under the more general Economics rubric.)  I look forward to interviewing authors on a variety of finance and investment-related topics (and the occasional work on Russian history or aviation!). Please get in touch if you have a book coming out, or if you’d like to join me as a co-host. I am looking for both. Previous interviews can be seen at https://newbooksnetwork.com/category/politics-society/finance/  

Continue Reading

NewBooksNetwork interview with the author of The Enlightened Capitalists.

The chorus of criticisms about our basic capitalist system grows louder and louder, now from leading capitalists themselves. (https://tinyurl.com/y293eabx) While other leading practitioners defend a market-based system against government-led systems, they too acknowledge that the market approach is leaving too many people behind.  (https://tinyurl.com/y3ed32dy) It doesn’t have to be this way. In his new book, James O’Toole, emeritus professor of business ethics at USC, highlights the history and potential of ethical capitalism.  In The Enlightened Capitalists: Cautionary Tales of Business Pioneers Who Tried to Do Well by Doing Good (HarperBusiness, 2019), O’Toole tells the tale of two dozen entrepreneurs who resisted …

Continue Reading

Capitalism

Capitalism is under attack, in the US, in France, pretty much any where you look.  Whether for reasons of income or wealth inequality or the damage being done to the planet, a lot of people are blaming the system. My question is, “Which capitalism?” Is it the stick-figure University of Chicago version reflected in the orthodox finance model and in your MBA program and CFA curriculum?  The damage it has done to investors in the stock market is the topic of Getting Back to Business, but it is too much to say it is responsible for all the ills of …

Continue Reading

Adam Smith, redux

A decade ago or so ago, one of the jokes making the rounds in Hollywood was that the hottest screenwriter in town was Jane Austen.  Now one of her contemporaries—albeit a generation earlier—is crushing it in finance. Adam Smith passed away in 1790, but he is making a big-time come back. And it is not for his undergraduate standard, The Wealth of Nations (published in 1776 and expanded in 1784), but for his earlier and broader The Theory of Moral Sentiments (published in 1759 and revised nearly continuously until he died). Smith considered this his magnum opus, with Wealth of Nations serving as a specific application …

Continue Reading

The source of the problem…..

How did the abstract theories of the great classical economists become specific and rigid policy prescriptions for modern life, including MPT? Here’s how. Listen to David Colander explain how the “Chicago” school changed the rules. David Colander and Craig Freedman, “Where Economics Went Wrong: Chicago’s Abandonment of Classical Liberalism” (Princeton UP, 2018)    

Continue Reading

It works on the way down too.

The notion that the value of an asset would rise with the sustainable increase in distributable cashflows from said asset is not a controversial notion in the business world. It is, however, not the accepted wisdom in the US stock market where the rules have been different for several decades, and where paying a dividend—even a rising one—is derided as giving up on growth. Despite that adverse environment, most US stocks when measured over long periods still observe the basic rules of business. In other words, stocks go up because dividends go up. That’s the recurrent theme in The Strategic …

Continue Reading

Share buybacks and the race for dogcatcher, 2020.

Wall Street’s reputation, already quite bad on Main Street, has turned …. esoteric.  To the surprise of many, an “inside-baseball” stock market practice, the share buyback, has become an early issue in the 2020 presidential campaign. Go figure.  The first salvo was fired in the New York Times by two prominent Democrats, one of whom has run for President before and might again. A high-profile Republican senator, also a former White House contender and probable future one, could not resist temptation and chimed in with his view and proposal.  The back and forth has led the financial chattering class to …

Continue Reading

Accounting matters……

Had the pleasure of interviewing Ian Gow and Stuart Kells, authors of The Big Four, a new history of the modern audit industry. Fascinating and frightening at the same time. Listen here: Ian D. Gow and Stuart Kells, “The Big Four: The Curious Past and Perilous Future of the Global Accounting Monopoly” (Berrett-Koehler Publishers, 2018)    

Continue Reading

Enjoying the volatility???

Year-to-date, the US stock market, as measured by the broad S&P 500 Index is roughly flat, with a -1.4% change in price (thru 12/11), augmented by nearly 2% in dividends distributed and accrued. It surely has not felt that way.  In January, the S&P rocketed up 7.5% in less than one month, and then fell over 10% in 10 days in late January and early February. From late March through September, the market rose steadily to a 9% gain before the up-and-down action in the fourth quarter brought the year-to-date returns back to around zero. Start Finish Price return % …

Continue Reading

Equity duration, part II

Following up on my post from November 1, here is a matrix of the Macaulay durations for a range of equity portfolios.  The conclusion is obvious: the amount of the upfront payment is far more significant in determining equity duration than the growth rate. The incremental growth rate, and the incremental expected return or discount rate, ends up being almost trivial in the calculation.   Cash is king.   Macaulay Duration Matrix for Equity Portfolios The “Dividend” Market The Stock Market The “Dividend Growth” Market Yield 4.0% 4.0% 4.0% 2.0% 2.0% 2.0% 2.0% 2.0% 3.0% 3.0% 3.0% 3.0% 3.0% Div …

Continue Reading

Two podcasts released….

In the past month or so, I’ve been interviewed by several podcasters. The crispest is Michael Covel’s Trendfollowing podcast, episode 711. You can listen to it here.   There is also an interview on Jay Coulter’s The Resilient Advisor podcast.   Note: The views expressed here are those of the author alone, and do not necessarily reflect the views of his employer. Nothing written here should be construed as investment advice. Consult your investment advisor for specific recommendations.

Continue Reading

If it were easy, everyone would do it….

James Mackintosh’s Streetwise column in Today’s WSJ (behind a paywall for non-subscribers) tells the tale of a American industrial giant that had to cut its dividend twice this year, most recently down to a penny a share. As Mackintosh wrote, “The business has been eating its seed corn recently, partly to maintain the dividend.” Mackintosh seems to blame “irrational” investors for placing too much emphasis on dividend payments, and managers for being cajoled into making dividend payments when the company really needed to push less, not more, cash out the door.  He ends by repeating the flawed Miller & Modigliani dividend irrelevancy …

Continue Reading

Interview with the authors of Cents and Sensibility:

A few months ago, I had the pleasure of interviewing Mihir Desai, author of The Wisdom of Finance.  He used great works of literature to show how the rules of finance could play out in peoples lives, and to make those rules less distant and incomprehensible. Gary Saul Morson and Morton Schapiro go a step further and argue that great literature has something to teach the economists hiding behind their rigid formulas and Spock-like utility maximizing rational actors. Good judgment, they write, “cannot be reduced to any theory or set of rules.” Listen to the interview here  

Continue Reading

Escaping the near-termism of the capital markets.

One of the key points made in Getting Back to Business is that the daily repricing of assets in the stock market, and the “near-termism” that can result, ends up leading both company managers and investors astray. As a potential solution, I argue in favor of having both focus on cashflows, which are generally much more stable, and lend themselves to longer-term analysis and investment. The challenge of near-termism showed up in two completely separate forums this week. In the first, the Buttonwood column in the October 27 issue of the Economist, very likely now behind a paywall, points out the …

Continue Reading

Reserve currency status….

The historian in me frequently notes that too many people operating in finance assume that the “rules” are static, and everlasting.  That’s the case of MPT, as argued in Getting Back to Business. It’s also the case in regard to the US dollar’s status as the world’s reserve currency. A recent Bloomberg Businessweek article by Peter Coy, “The Tyranny of the U.S. Dollar,” (October 8) reviews the status of the greenback as the dominant currency in global affairs and why it might or might not remain that way. (One factor in favor of the dollar is that there is no …

Continue Reading

Risk-free rates….really?

In Getting Back to Business, I call into question the notion of a “risk free” rate, to which one adds a certain incremental amount to determine the appropriate overall risk (and expected return) of an investment. According to today’s FT, consumers in Italy are asking (sort of) the same question, as they become unusually aware of and focused on the spread between Italian government bonds and those of the “risk-free” investment source, German bunds.

Continue Reading

Relevance….

Whatever the flaws of Getting Back to Business, irrelevance to portfolio management is not one of them. The book provides a critical history of the current paradigm, and then proposes an alternative approach, written from the perspective of an active practitioner overseeing one of the largest dividend complexes in the country. So I had to laugh when a leading journal in the field of investment management declined to review the book, writing to my publicist, “Not that kind of journal.” Alas, this is consistent with how I expected the book to be received by the academic community, as discussed in …

Continue Reading